“I shout at people for practicing a defensive shot. It’s a wasted ball.”
And it seems the people shout at themselves too.
An awkward silence interrupted what had been a free-flowing conversation. “Let’s not put that into the story,” Morgan joked.
In hindsight, that principle is the essence of the approach because batters don’t just hope to score runs anymore, they actively look to do it.
“When you sit back and watch people bat, the very, very best always look to score first, and then, if it’s a good ball and you can’t score off it, you play a defensive shot,” Morgan said. “It takes a lot of drilling over the years but I don’t think it [the block] is at the forefront of everybody’s thinking now, whereas previously it was.”
He can be credited with being one of the architects of this batting revolution. There have been others, of course: Sri Lanka’s approach to the first 15 overs in ODI cricket around the 1996 World Cup was remarkable at the time. Morgan’s philosophy came to the fore in England after the 2015 World Cup, where they failed to make the quarter-finals. He described their exit as a “humiliation” and pinned their underperformance on their inability to score quickly enough or take advantage of changing playing conditions, which created fewer boundary riders.
“The best teams in the world were scoring upwards of 350 in every game they played and taking on extra risks with the rule of the extra man having to be up in the 30-yard circle the whole time. That was something we were falling behind in,” Morgan said. “To rectify that gap, part of the change was to recruit players, who, when they made mistakes or were put under pressure, their default was to be aggressive and really put the opposition under pressure.”
Although it sounds like strike rate and boundary count would have been key to this kind of strategy, Morgan said it was actually how each ball was played that mattered. “It was about putting each bowler under pressure if you were given the opportunity. If you look for opportunities, they appear more often than if you weren’t looking for them. So trying to create those opportunities by imposing yourself on the game was part of it.”
That means just about any player who wants to play this way can. It’s not an approach only for those with long levers or a strong swing. It’s not about being able to use one’s feet to play shots like the sweep or reverse sweep or about timing or placement. It’s about the psyche of the person with the bat in the hand.
“It’s not technique at all. It’s all about mindset. It’s about accessing a part of your brain that you might not use early on in your innings, traditionally, but you might use it later on,” Morgan said. “You see it in every country around the world. On certain days, countries produce unbelievable performances and post big scores. It’s just a matter of trying to group them together and do it as consistently as possible. Within the England group, at the time , we felt that even if we fell short, we would still post a bigger score than if we played defensively.”
And then it’s about the reassurance that if there is a blowout, it won’t result in batters losing their places. “Throughout the journey, when we would fall short of posting a big score and not getting as many as we would have liked, it was important for the leadership group and the coaching staff to reinforce the message of what we were trying to achieve and trying to change,” Morgan said.
The result was that England’s 50-over run rate improved from 5.34 runs an over between 2009 and 2015 to 6.24 runs an over from 2016 onwards – an increase of 16.9%. That’s almost one more run per over, which means that over the course of an innings, it’s almost 50 more runs. In T20I cricket, the difference showed in the totals they posted – going from 160 to scores above 175.
As for England’s Test team, we only need to say one word: Bazball. Though Morgan does not play red-ball cricket anymore, he credited the Ben Stokes-Brendon McCullum takeover with producing “some of the best Test match series I’ve ever watched in my life” and fundamentally altering ideas that have been in place since Test cricket’s inception in 1877.
“What England have proved this year  is that you can play Test cricket in that [T20] fashion,” Morgan said. “It’s made for unbelievable entertainment. It’s created a new level of interest and proved that you don’t have to play Test cricket one way, particularly as a batter, which for, I suppose the 150 years, has always been one way.”
“They are proving that it’s possible to play like this anywhere,” Morgan said. “One of the sad things is that people continue to question it but they’ve gone undefeated using the same mantra and it’s brilliant.”
“I like it because for a long time, particularly with English batters, our defense has been missing. I like that we are taking the game on,” Morgan said. “I feel as if Ben and Brendon sit back and watch the players play and think that they’re unbelievably talented, so why don’t we see more of this in the game? And let’s use our strengths to impose ourselves on the game instead of going to somebody else’s strengths because they said that’s how you play Test cricket. It’s using the talent they have to the best of everybody’s ability.”
And best of all, it’s enjoyable and individualised, so everyone feels like they can just be themselves. “It looks like so much fun,” Morgan said. “And when you look at some of them – Jonny Bairstow’s innings, Joe Root’s innings – the character really comes out in the innings, as opposed to it just being a normal Test 50 or 100 or 150. You get a sense of what the character in the change room is like.”
All that said, is it only England who can do it? “In the shorter format, every batter has the ability to play aggressively,” Morgan said. “I don’t know any batters that don’t play all around the ground. Every batter now has an array of shots.”
The SA20 has also opened South African cricket up to the world of T20 franchise leagues, where innovation is a key aspect, and, so far, it has lived up to the hype. The first two weeks had sellout crowds, a good mix of conditions, from the slow, turning wicket at Boland Park to the pacy Centurion strip, and several local players showcasing their best.
Morgan believes the SA20 has the ingredients to transform South African cricket, especially against the backdrop of their worrying form since the 2019 World Cup, but for now, he just wants to make sure none of the Royals batters are practicing the block.
“Playing in the inaugural year of a tournament is great. It’s very organic, things normally flow and it’s very exciting,” he said. “And also, we play in stadiums where there are no grass banks. In South Africa, they still have them. When the grass bank is full, it creates that carnival atmosphere, which is nice.”
Nicer perhaps when there’s someone hitting the ball onto them, is what he didn’t say.